Fitch downgrades ICICI Bank, revises Axis Bank rating to negative

Fitch has downgraded its support rating for ICICI Bank from ‘2’ to ‘3’ and revised the outlook on Axis Bank to ‘negative’ from ‘stable’.

The outlook on ICICI Bank is, however, ‘stable’.

Support ratings reflect expectation of a moderate probability of extraordinary state (government) support, if required. This is due to private ownership and lower systemic importance compared to larger banks.

The revision in ICICI’s support rating takes into account the constrained finances. A large number of weak government-owned banks — particularly those which are systemically important — will get priority in terms of timeliness of government support.

It affirmed the long-term issuer default ratings (IDRs) and viability ratings of ICICI Bank and Axis Bank at ‘BBB-’ and ‘bbb-’, respectively.

The negative outlook on Axis’s rating reflects rising pressure on its standalone profile relative to banks with a viability rating of ‘bbb-’. The pressure on the profile stems from heightened asset-quality stress and weak earnings.

Axis Bank’s capital buffers are less comfortable for its current rating despite raising of fresh capital. ICICI’s capital buffers are better even though it experienced similar financial deterioration in the previous few years.

 

Both banks exhibit gaps in risk control. An ongoing investigation into ICICI with regard to extending a loan with potential conflict of interest has also focused the authorities’ attention on the bank’s governance.

Adverse findings could lead to reputation risk, particularly if they point to broader weaknesses in the management.

Fitch has a negative sector outlook on Indian banks. The new regulatory non-performing loan (NPL) framework that has accelerated bad-loan recognition is part of a clean-up that should improve the banking sector’s health in the long term.

Most state-owned banks reported losses in the financial year ending March 2018 (FY18) and earnings of large private banks also came under significant pressure, with Axis reporting its first-ever quarterly loss.